I periodically take sojourns into books of the Bible, and right now I’m emerging from a sojourn in Leviticus. Wrapping my brain around the varieties of sacrifice and what they each might express has been profitable. But I’m still left with questions about the terms that regularly get translated “clean” and “unclean.” I wrestled with it in the sermon Sunday. (My text was Lev 5:1-13, and “unclean” comes into play in verses 2-3 there. In fact, that’s the first time the term appears in the Torah.)
In seminary, Dr. Lisa Davison taught us that “unclean” described a state where life and death mixed in extra-ordinary ways. The things that make people “unclean” are (generally speaking) human and animal corpses, male and female genital discharges, and the term that usually gets translated “leprosy.” Corpses obviously have to do with death. The blood and “seed” from male and female discharges represent life outside of its usual context. (That is, the life is in the blood, but it either should be going back to God or be inside a living creature. “Seed” is not to be carelessly spilled, because it is also life.) And “leprosy,” we discover in Numbers 12 when Miriam is given the disease, makes one resemble something dead.
The only practical implications of being “unclean” are that you can’t enter the tabernacle/Temple (which is where the presence of God is supposed to reside), nor can you partake of any sacred meals. To do so in a state of “uncleanness” is grounds for being “cut off from the people.” (Lev 7:21) We are left wondering why this is. The best I can figure is that there is some problem with the co-mingling of life and death that is “uncleanness” being brought into the presence of the Living God. The laws of “uncleanness” are a ritual expression of the chasm between God and humanity, the broken relationship between them. God desires life, not death. “I have no pleasure in the death of anyone,” says God in Ezekiel 18:32.
But this seems odd in the face of all the slaughtered cattle of the burnt offerings and all the slaughtered babies of the Tenth Plague before the Exodus and all the slaughtered Canaanites of the book of Joshua. The best I can figure about these is that they each represent not only death, but life “returning to God who gave it” (Ecc 12:7). The God who “owns the cattle on a thousand hills” (Ps 50:10) receives the life of the slaughtered animals in the burnt offering. The God who says “all the firstborn are mine” (Num 3:12) takes the firstborn of Egypt and also requires the firstborn of Israel be “redeemed.” And the slaughtered Canaanites are called “cherem,” a thing “devoted” to the Lord. The same term is applied in Lev 27:21 to consecrated fields, holy to the Lord. Somehow, things that are “cherem” or “devoted to destruction” belong to God.
Perhaps what is at issue here is not simply the co-mingling of life and death, but God getting what is God’s. In the cases of the slaughtered Egyptian firstborn, the slaughtered cattle of the burnt offering, and the slaughtered Canaanites who are “devoted to destruction,” God is taking what is God’s. The life returns to the God who gave it. But in the cases of unburied corpses and carcasses, gential discharges, and leprosy, life is not being returned to God. Rather, Death is entering the picture apart from the will of God. Chaos, God’s enemy from the first chapter of Genesis, is raising its ugly head and robbing God of what belongs to God. The laws of “uncleanness” are not simply about humanity’s separation from God, but God’s opposition to the powers of death and chaos which are ingrained in the universe.
Death, of course, is “the last enemy to be destroyed,” as Paul reminds us in 1 Corinthians 15:26. Death is a problem for the God who loves humankind for “in death there is no remembrance of you [God]; in Sheol who can give you praise?” (Psalm 6:5 among other places). God seeks to subdue the whole creation, even the power of death, so that life that seems lost to death is actually life received by God. We notice what happens when Jesus comes into contact with “uncleanness”: he raises corpses, he cleanses lepers, and he heals the “woman with the issue of blood.” In Jesus, God’s victory over death is decisively revealed.
So the “uncleanness” regulations demonstrate that God does not desire to lose anybody or anything in creation to the power of death working apart from the power of God. The fact that God will not lose anybody or anything in creation to the power of death working apart from the power of God is demonstrated in Jesus Christ, and especially in his cross and resurrection. The powers of chaos, of death, of ignorance, of disease, are all only temporary. Everything must eventually go back to the God who made it.
